Flick Direct’s Water for Elephants Review *Spoilers*   1 comment

Water for Elephants stars Robert Pattinson and Reese Witherspoon as two people who find love amidst the Great Depression while working for a traveling circus. The movie is based on the acclaimed bestseller by Sara Gruen and directed by Francis Lawrence.

Pattinson plays Jacob Jankowski, a veterinary student looking forward to starting his career. Tragedy strikes when Jacob’s parents are killed in an accident and Jacob, in a last minute decision, decides to abandon his studies. He runs away and one night hops aboard a passing train. He discovers that the train he boarded is in actuality a traveling circus that has seen better days.

Read the rest after the jump


After some initial difficulties he is accepted into the group when they discover that he was training in the care of animals. He is placed in charge of the menagerie of animals the circus has and it is there he meets Marlena (Reese Witerspoon). She is in charge of the horse act of the show and is married to August (Christoph Waltz) the animal trainer. August comes off extremely charming and it is clear that he has the approval of everyone in the troupe, perhaps except for Marlena. It is soon discovered that while August is fascinating he has a cruel streak hiding underneath.

He is exceptionally cruel to the animals he is meant to train and since he possesses the trust of those he works with, there has never been any reason to question his methods. The real story here is the love story that builds between Marlena and Jacob. They develop a bond over an unpleasant elephant by the name of Rosie, who has given all of those who attempt to train her, a hard time. Jacob truly has within him a deep and honest love for animals and it is that which allows him to find a way to reach Rosie where others could not.

This draws the attention of Marlena and as she gets to know Jacob more her feelings for him deepen and the same goes for him in regards to her. As their feelings grow Jacob realizes that Marlena is not truly happy with August. The longer they spend time together the more difficult it becomes for them to resist the feelings they have for one another. Jacob finally decides that he won’t spend another day without Marlena and asks her to come away with him, but Jacob does not account for August and his dangerous personality.

Water for Elephants tells a beautiful tale of love during a time when even acquiring a simple meal was nearly impossible. Given the time period the movie takes place in, it does a fantastic job of creating a rich look to the places it presents. Every scene, even those depicting true hardship, has a crisp and sharp look to it. The two leads in the film give worthy performances; Witherspoon has proven herself over the years to be a versatile and capable actress. Here she does a delivers another solid performance against a male lead that, so far, has been limited by the Twilight films in that it gives no room for range or depth.

Pattinson himself does well bringing a sense of caring and love that his character carry’s for the animals he takes care of. The large problem with the film is the chemistry between the leads. While we know they are supposed to find love with one another and it does happen in the film, it never actually feels like they should be getting together. It simply happens because that is what they are supposed to do, the script says it and so they play along.

It’s this flaw in the film that really keeps it from becoming something more than what it is; otherwise the movie does an adequate job of creating a story of two people overcoming incredible odds during a time when even love was a luxury that few could afford. 

— Chris Rebholz


One response to “Flick Direct’s Water for Elephants Review *Spoilers*

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. Pingback: Water for Elephants/Come l’acqua per gli Elefanti, nelle recensioni dei giornali americani (Rassegna stampa)/parte 1 - RobertPattinsonMoms

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.